The New Italian Oven Information

The New Italian Oven, located at 623 Highland Ave in Connellsville, PA, has quickly become a beloved local spot for anyone craving delicious, authentic Italian cuisine. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this cozy diner-style restaurant serves up mouthwatering dishes that leave you coming back for more.

The menu at The New Italian Oven offers a variety of Italian classics, with standout dishes like their perfectly cooked penne pasta, fresh salads, and the always popular stromboli. Each dish is prepared with care, ensuring that every bite is packed with flavor. One thing that stands out about their stromboli is that it’s never too greasy or messy, a common issue with similar dishes at other restaurants. The balance between crispy crust and savory filling is just right.

Another crowd favorite is the hot pepper cheese sticks, which are the perfect appetizer to kick off your meal. The cheese is always melted to perfection, and the seasoning adds the ideal amount of heat without overwhelming the taste. Many customers have praised the consistency in the quality of the food, with several noting how even under new ownership, The New Italian Oven has maintained the charm and familiarity that makes it special.

The restaurant’s staff also plays a big part in its appeal. Servers, like Kate, are often mentioned in reviews for their attentive and friendly service. Guests appreciate that staff members remember their orders and are thorough in ensuring everything is just right. One reviewer shared how Kate’s politeness and excellent service made their dining experience stand out. This level of service is something that keeps customers coming back time after time.

If you're on the go, The New Italian Oven also offers convenient takeout options. Several visitors have shared how smooth and easy the takeout experience is, with meals prepared quickly and just as delicious as when enjoyed in the restaurant. One traveler noted that they were able to get their order exactly how they wanted it, with a quick turnaround time, all while on a road trip.

Whether you're stopping by for a sit-down meal with the family or grabbing a quick bite to go, The New Italian Oven delivers great food and excellent service, making it a must-visit spot in Connellsville, PA.

Open Times

Monday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Tuesday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Wednesday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Thursday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Friday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Saturday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Sunday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

The food was great, we had penne pasta, a salad, stromboli and hot pepper cheese sticks. Everything cooked to perfection. The Stromboli was not too greasy or messy, it was cooked perfectly. Wow. My server Kate was great. She was a young girl who is kind, polite, attentive, remembered everything, and very thorough. she was the best server I’ve had in a very long time. Also pleased that even under new ownership the classic things that made the Italian oven so enjoyable for my child is still there, the table sheets with crayons and of course the hand drawings on the window.

I ordered a few meals to go while driving past on a roadtrip. I was greeted over that phone with a delightful lady taking my order who easily handled my sauce change request. She had our meals ready to go when I arrived and the taste was on point!

Staff and food are great. 10 stars would not be enough! I wish we had one close to home but I’ll drive 55 minutes to eat here again.

Love the food here! The best part is that they don’t skimp on portions…even when ordering takeout, the portions are robust! The staff who handles the phones are kind and professional

Service was great! Our waitress was super friendly. Food was awesome as well. Definitely recommend the zucchini as an appetizer. There was a bit of a wait in between courses but for quality food I don’t mind waiting and that’s exactly what this was. Portions are very filling, we both left with leftovers we ate for the next two days. For sure a hot spot to try out!

The food was so delicious, I got a New York strip steak and it came with bread and a salad/potato and you could tell that bread was fresh baked there, and all the food was delicious but also the atmosphere was fantastic. Super cozy with adorable Halloween decor and very clean. Haven’t been inside a restaurant that looked like to before! Very unique

The New Italian Oven